Skip to content

State Farm® Insurance Agent Natalie Arnett

120 W. MacArthur St. #150
Shawnee, OK 74804

Billy Boy's and Paul's Place Complex

Profile photo of a State Farm Agent named: Natalie Arnett

Would you like to create a personalized quote?

Office Info

Office Hours

9am - 5pm
After Hours by Appointment
Call us 24 hours a day!


120 W. MacArthur St. #150
Shawnee, OK 74804



I am a life-long resident of Shawnee and a proud supporter of our community. Born to public servants of this community , I have deep roots in Pottawatomie County and I am passionate about enhancing the areas where we live and are raising families.

I am a graduate of Shawnee High School, and have a Bachelor’s degree from East Central University, Go Tigers! I have been married to William for over 25 years. Together, we have 3 children and one little grand dude!

Prior to becoming an agent, I worked for Berkshire Hathaway Benchmark Realty, in Shawnee and the surrounding areas. Years of experience in the housing market has provided an excellent foundation for a better understanding of your insurance needs. My agency opened in October 2019, and I have enjoyed serving nearly 4 years as a State Farm agent for Shawnee, Tecumseh, and Seminole, and Meeker, Harrah, Newalla, and surrounding areas.

If you know me at all, you know I am a people loving person! I enjoy networking, helping others, investing in our education system and our children. I currently serve as the second vice-president of Shawnee's Rotary club, a member of Shawnee Forward's Ambassadors, and as the President of the Tecumseh Touchdown Club. In my spare time, I'm a cheerleader for all things my kids are involved in. I also love to travel, read, and to dance.

Our #ArnettAgency welcomes the opportunity to help customers with their insurance and financial service needs. Our goal is to prepare our customers for life's unexpected events. My experienced team of insurance ladies are ready to help our customers find just the right policy for auto insurance, homeowners insurance, renters insurance, life insurance, and more. We are licensed in both Oklahoma and Texas to better serve all of your insurance needs. Stop by and say hello. We love visitors!

Insurance Products Offered

Auto, Homeowners, Condo, Renters, Personal Articles, Business, Life, Health

Other Products

Banking, Annuities, Home Loans

Skip Infinite Scroll Facebook Feed

My team and I pride ourselves on educating and empowering our customers to make informed decisions regarding protecting those you love most. We are here to help with your home, auto, life, health, & business needs! We strive to be your partners in protection!

Our team is made up of dedicated members that are proud residents of Shawnee and surrounding areas. We are engaged members of our local communities. Stop by and meet our fantastic team. Natalie Rachel, Anna, Jaiden, and Sarah are happy to take care of you and your family!

Rachel Treat State Farm Agent Team Member

Rachel Treat

Multiple Line Representative

Rachel has been with us since 2019 as our Sales Leader. You will know its her when she answers the phone because of her southern drawl. She got her degree in Human Relations in 2009 from Oklahoma University. She loves to help people find the right coverage for home, auto, health & life insurance. She's originally from Texas, but has been an Oklahoma resident since 2005.

Rachel has three kids who attend Harrah Public Schools. She's been married her husband Shane since 2008. You will probably find in her the dance studio cheering on her daughter. In her free time, she's hanging out with her family at the lake.

Rachel in licensed in Property, Casualty, Life and Health insurance in OK.

Anna Rucker State Farm Agent Team Member

Anna Rucker

Account Associate

Anna Rucker has been working in insurance since 2018 as an account associate, and is also our claim assistant. Anna is licensed in Property & Casualty Insurance with the state of OK. She has a passion for helping people, and truly loves Shawnee.

Anna is from a small town in Oklahoma but has lived in Shawnee since 2014. She got her bachelor's in Communication Studies from Oklahoma Baptist University (go Bison!).

She has been married to her high school sweetheart since 2018 and has two cats. She loves hot tea, coffee, & anything made out of potatoes.

Jaiden Balthrop State Farm Agent Team Member

Jaiden Balthrop

Account Associate

Jaiden Balthrop has been apart of our team since August 2021. She works as an account associate and assists customers however needed!

Jaiden is a licensed Property & Casualty team member. She is originally from the Tulsa area and is currently a student at Oklahoma Baptist University (go with ka-rip)!

She is majoring in Social Entrepreneurship and Management, and ultimately hopes to serve people in whatever community she is in. When not doing work or school Jaiden loves cross stitching, plant shopping, and spending time with her friends!

William Arnett State Farm Agent Team Member

William Arnett

Agent's Assistant

After a 25 year career in Law Enforcement, Natalie was finally able to convince Will to join the team.

He is licensed in Property & Casualty in Oklahoma, but can most likely be found working behind the scenes to make the agency run efficiently. 

He is often helping with events, day to day maintenance, etc.,. He also spends a lot of time in the field helping with site inspections, photos, and running a lot of errands for the Agent! 

He is a proud graduate of Tecumseh High School, where you can still find him supporting his hometown team today often. 


Sarah Farrell

Customer Service Representative